mumsnet
Showing posts with label Children's nursing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Children's nursing. Show all posts

Thursday, 3 October 2013

Ouch! Why is it so hard to assess children's pain?

The simple answer it is difficult to assess pain full stop, because pain is by definition subjective, the classic definition being that it is whatever the experiencing person says it is.  With children of course there is the added complication of developmental issues, in particular the inability to verbalise pain.

To get round this, there are a large number of different pain assessment tools and scales, ranging in complexity from a straight line with no pain at one end and the worst imaginable pain at the other; to quite sophisticated behavioural tools, which try to identify behaviours associated with pain.  The problem remains though; how do you know when someone who can't verbalise pain is in pain, and how do you know your treatment is working?

A new study has looked at two tools that are fairly commonly used, a 'faces' scale and a colour intensity scale.  The first has faces that reflect differing degrees of discomfort; the second a graduated colour scale, where more intense colour is associated with greater pain.  In my travels around hospitals in the UK, I have to say that I see these scales a lot, but I rarely see them actually used.  Never mind lets press on with the study.

They looked at the reliability and validity of these tools in children aged between 4 and 17 years in the United States who had painful and non-painful conditions; and compared the two tools.  When you are assessing how useful tools such as this are, there are two key things that people look for:
  1. Validity - is it actually measuring what you think it is (in this case is it measuring pain, or might it be measuring something else, such as mood?)
  2. Reliability - how consistent is it, in other words if you measured the same thing twice at the same time, would you get the same answer?
They actually did some quite sophisticated tests here, and found that overall the tools seemed to work quite well.  However, there is a but..

Firstly, the children were quite old; and there was least agreement between the tools in the youngest age-group, which is the very children in which it is hardest to measure pain.  Secondly, validity is context specific.  Just because it works with these children in this place at this time, it does not mean it is going to work elsewhere.  Watch for this one, the famous 'validated tool' which people talk about without often knowing the circumstances of the validation.  For example, a tool validated among old people in New York is not likely to be valid for children in Bolton.  You may think this sounds far fetched (and it is a bit) but I have seen similar claims made.  Lastly just because two tools agree, it doesn't make them right - they could both be wrong.  Often people refer to a 'gold standard' measure and compare a new measure to this, but even then there can be problems, for example the existing standard may itself not be very good.  Everyone 'agreed' about banking 5 years ago - it is just a shame that they were all wrong.

For parents my suggestion is to know your child's pain behaviours, and make sure that when you are with healthcare professionals you make them know that you know!

Tsze (2013) validation of self-report pain scales in children.  Pediatrics 132 e971-979

Sunday, 8 September 2013

Guidlines-keep them simple otherwise we won't remember them! The example of weight estimation.


One of the most important variables in paediatrics is development, and one important measure of physical development is weight.  This is used for all sorts of things, including drug doses, fluid calculations and body surface area estimation.  Normally of course we can weigh children, so this should be pretty accurate.

Unfortunately, sometimes we can’t do this, most notably in emergency situations; and in such cases it is necessary to estimate the child’s weight.  While this is never going to be as accurate as weighing the child, a good estimate is the best that can often be achieved.  However, this obviously requires two things: 
  1. A formula for estimating weight
  2. That the person using it can remember it and use it correctly.
A number of methods for estimating weight exist, however a recent letter published in Archives of Disease in Childhood describing a survey among 25 paediatric trainees suggest that this may be a cause of some confusion.   The authors start by reviewing the current Advanced Paediatric Life Support (APLS) Guidelines, which contain three methods of estimating weight:

·         Infants from 1-12 months (0.5 x age in months +4)
·         Children aged 1-5 years (2 x age in years +8)
·         Children aged 6-12 years (3 x age in years +7)

These replace the previous Guidelines which had one formula for children aged 1-10 years, and which still used in some Guidelines.

The study found that only 2 of the participants (8%) were able to correctly apply the new formulae to examples that they were given, and that around half used the old formula.  The extent to which this matters is debatable, but clearly someone thought it was worth changing the guidance on this, and this is what is now taught, so one would expect that paediatric trainees at least would know them.

The lesson from this is that Guidelines should always be as simple as possible if we expect people to remember them.  For parents, it might be worth knowing roughly how much your child weighs!

Wednesday, 28 August 2013

Diagnosing infection in children – what is the problem?


One of the big problems in terms of treating children is diagnosing the illness in the first place.  In no group is this more of a challenge than in infants with infections, because many of the classical signs of infection, such as inflammation are absent because of their relatively immature immunity.  A similar problem occurs with people of all ages whose immune systems are damaged, either by disease, old-age, or sometimes medical treatment.  The key to diagnosing infection is often not the bug, but the immune response to the bug, and if you don’t have a good immune response it makes it all the more difficult.  Often the only sign of infection is a fever, hence the importance of fever as a diagnostic sign in immunosuppressed people.

The answer to this is to either have a very low suspicion for disease, which might mean over-treating; or to have a higher suspicion, but then risk missing disease.  The problem with the first is that it is expensive, and in the case of antibiotics might lead to the development of resistance; while the latter leads to the risk of missing potentially fatal infections.  It was partly for this reason that the NICE Guidelines on the treatment of fever in children were developed, but many of the symptoms in the amber and red categories are fairly general, and anyway they don’t tell you what infection the child has, just that they probably do have one.

The answer is better and quicker diagnostic tests.  We have a whole range of tests now, but none that are completely accurate.  Additionally, some are highly dependent on the skills of the person performing the tests or on the organism itself: for example, blood cultures, the gold standard test for many infections may become contaminated with skin bacteria, or the bacteria themselves may not grow in the lab.  Even if they do grow, it is not always the case that the bacteria that grow are the ones actually causing the disease; and there may be other organisms, for example viruses or fungi that do not grow in the lab.  Such methods are sometimes referred to as 'phenotypic' - they look for behaviours such as growth or the response to different conditions or chemicals.  If the thing is dead in the test tube or does not grow it won't have a phenotype!

There are many new diagnostic techniques that avoid such problems being developed, some of which are reviewed in a recent paper in JAMA Pediatrics.  In particular these are tending to use molecular methods to either identify the pathogen directly, such as those which look for the genes of the organism; or to identify the host response to the organism.  The latter is helped by the rapidly increasing knowledge of the human immune system and genomic techniques. These methods don’t rely on culturing (‘growing’) the organism in the lab, and so avoid many of the problems inherent in observing growth or behaviour, but they bring their own issues, not least of which is expense.  One method, known as PCR(Polymerase Chain Reaction) which looks for pathogen genomes has been used for some time, and is widely used to diagnose HIV in young children, but is not widely used elsewhere for diagnostic purposes.  Molecular is definitely the way forward, but it may not be a quick journey.

The lesson from this is that testing is fine, but it must not replace the clinical judgement of either parents or healthcare professionals.  Even if you have the best diagnostic test in the world…..ever, it still relies on someone to notice that the child is ill in the first place.  Parents and clinicians are both, in their own ways, generally quite good at this, and so should trust their instincts.  Incidentally, if you want to know if someone really understands this stuff ask them: if they say yes - they probably don't!  There is much of the immune system, and our relationship with micro organisms that we don't understand and probably never will.

Sunday, 11 August 2013

More children being admitted to hospital in the UK - why and what can be done?

According to a study recently published in Archives of Disease in Childhood it appears that more children are being admitted to  hospital (Gill et al 2008 Arch Dis Child 98 328-334).  While the figures are a bit rough and ready, the trends presented are fairly clear and include:
  1. A fairly continuous increase in the number of admissions since 2003; in the preceding 4 years (1999-2003) it was fairly static.
  2. Overall the increase in admissions since 1999 is 28%: in those under 1 year of age it is 33% which is the highest, the lowest was in the 10-14 year age group which was only (!) 13%.
  3. This increase is not because children are getting much sicker, as mortality fell over the same period.
  4. Much of the increase is the result of infectious diseases and other conditions such as asthma that could be managed in the community.
  5. Admissions for chronic conditions fell a little.
  6. Most of the increase was for very short stays, the largest increase being among children admitted for less than one day.
This presents a challenge, because this is clearly not sustainable, and is not good for the children concerned.  It is now over 50 years since the Platt Report which said, should only be admitted to hospital when "the medical treatment they require cannot be given in other ways without disadvantage."  Ironically, the report goes on to say "This may seem obvious but ...... evidence submitted to us suggests that it is still often overlooked."

What is even more perplexing is that over this same period there has been a strong emphasis upon caring for children in the community; provision of alternative methods of getting health care advice such as NHS Direct, the introduction of Children's Centres, and the publication of guidelines such as the NICE Fever Guidelines.

The authors give a long list of possible reasons for this increase.  These seem to fall into 3 categories:
  • Social - parents are less able or willing to look after children at home; or their threshold for seeking hospital advice is lower.
  • Clinical - more children are being sent to hospital by NHS Direct/GPs; hospitals are not as good at triaging as they were; or practice is becoming more defensive, leading to more children being admitted to be on the safe side
  • Organisational - admitting children to avoid breaching A&E targets by observing for longer; changes in contracts and financial incentives that reward admission.
Positives are that the increase in shorter stays may be party due to the fact that we discharge quicker.  That is about it for the positives!

Whatever the reason, this is not good and we must find a way of changing this trend.  One example of innovative thinking is the Traffic Light contained within the NICE Fever Guidelines which splits symptoms into categories (red, amber, green) which is designed to help divide symptoms into those indicative of high; low and intermediate risk of serious illness.  More is needed.  This may be an area where pharmaceutical companies can help, using their marketing expertise to produce quality parent friendly information.

Sunday, 14 July 2013

So you want to be a children's nurse?


Most Universities will be full for September now, but before you know it they will be interviewing for 2014, so if you want to be a children’s nurse, what might you think about in preparing for your application?  Here are some thoughts; but note I am not an admissions tutor (if I were I would not be able to do this!) and there are no guarantees, these are just some thoughts.  

Before you apply, think about where you want to go to University, but also remember that you will have placements that may start/finish at unsocial hours.  Find out where you will be doing placements and can you get there and home early in the morning and late at night, and at weekends?
Having done this, what about your statement and interview?  The first thing is, and I don’t want to sound patronising, but being a children’s nurse is not like being a nursery nurse, be clear that you know the difference.  I am not going to tell you what these differences are, if you want to be a nurse you should know or find that out, a hint however is that saying ‘I want to be a children’s nurse so that I can look after/because I like children’ is probably not going to be enough.  

Secondly, remember that although a lot of children’s nursing is done in hospital, even more is done out of hospital.  Nurses don’t just work with sick children, but increasingly with well children; trying to prevent disease as well as to treat it.  Even for children who are sick, they are looked after at home as far as possible.  This is where the future really lies, to find out more look up health visiting or community nursing on the search engine of your choice.

Thirdly, have some idea of what is going on both in the world, the nation, and in the NHS.  Look up a few recent reports and have some idea of what they said; for example try the Kennedy Report.   Don’t read the whole thing (unless you want to), when you get reports such as this look for something called the Executive Summary – it is all you need to know in a few pages.

Fourth, if you have trouble with maths, get some help.  You will have to do a maths test at some point – it will usually be at the interview stage, but you will also have to demonstrate your ability to do basic maths throughout the course.  This is crucial for the delivery of safe care; most children’s drugs for example are given according to weight (usually) or surface area, and so you need to be able to calculate these doses.

Fifth, remember children are not ‘little adults’; but developing individuals.  Think about children of different ages, and how they develop both physically and cognitively (how they think and understand the world).  For example, the heart rate of a baby is much higher than an adult; and a rash will seem different to a 3 year-old than to a 14 year-old.

Six, try and think about things from the child and families point of view; what do you think matters to them?  You might get some clues from this blog and other websites - but just think logically, even better, ask some children!

Finally, you need to be competent to practice as a nurse, but you also need to be nice.  Show this side: be assertive, but be polite; be professional, but smile; take part in group exercises, but don’t be too pushy.

Good luck!